Vergelijking: Hankook Ventus S1 evo3 K127 vs. Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S vs. Pirelli P ZERO PZ4

Premie

Hankook

Ventus S1 evo3 K127

VS

Pilot Sport 4 S

P ZERO PZ4

9.1

R13 – R23

Vergelijk ook met

SportContact 7

Ventus Evo

PremiumContact 7

Seasonproof wins on snow and silence; WeatherProof leads on efficiency and aquaplaning resistance.

Nokian is the Finnish brand that essentially invented the winter tyre, so when it comes to all-season rubber, its philosophy runs deeper than most. The Nokian Seasonproof and the Nokian WeatherProof occupy different positions within the brand's all-round lineup, and they reflect genuinely different priorities. The Seasonproof leans into what Nokian does best — confident winter and snow performance combined with exceptional ride comfort and near-silence on the motorway. The WeatherProof, meanwhile, is the more efficiency-focused sibling: outstanding aquaplaning resistance and very low rolling resistance, but a notably firmer and louder character. Neither is a bad tyre, but they suit very different drivers. Worth noting: the Seasonproof has since been updated as the Nokian Seasonproof 2, which carries a considerably higher overall rating — so buyers actively shopping should check whether the newer generation is available in their size.

Testprofiel

Ventus S1 evo3 K127

Pilot Sport 4 S

P ZERO PZ4

Aantal tests

19

10

14

Beste positie

#1

#2

Gemiddelde positie

6.1

2.1

5.5

Laatste test

2025

Beschikbare maten

109

193

700

Conclusie

Choose the Nokian Seasonproof if your winters are genuinely demanding — proper snowfall, cold mornings, icy roads — and you also value a quiet, comfortable ride for the other nine months of the year. It is the more rounded all-season in terms of winter capability and everyday refinement, and real-world owners with high mileages speak well of it. Just go in knowing that wet and dry braking distances are not its strength, and consider the updated Seasonproof 2 if it is available in your size. Choose the Nokian WeatherProof if fuel economy or EV range efficiency is a priority, or if you live somewhere with heavy rain but milder, less snowy winters — its aquaplaning resistance is genuinely impressive. But go in clear-eyed about the limitations: dry-road behaviour is the Achilles heel, and the tyre wears faster than most in this segment. For the majority of drivers seeking a comfortable, capable all-season from Nokian's range, the Seasonproof — or its successor — is the stronger overall choice.